How should we distribute Yabasic modules?
We could explicitly separate modules from the Yabasic core, distributing them individually so that users could download just the modules they wanted from a central location such as yabasic.basicprogramming.org. For example, a user could download yabasic.3.*.*.tar.gz, yabmod-sdl.*.tar.gz, and yabmod-curses.*.tar.gz and then install each of these components separately; and if our user later required (say) a FLTK module, it would be a simple matter to download and install yabmod-fltk.*.tar.gz. I'll need to take a closer look at the technicalities behind all of this to see exactly how such a system would function, but I doubt it would be too difficult to implement.
The alternative is to actually distribute modules with the Yabasic core. This approach has its benefits: users would only need to download one file (yabasic.3.*.*.tar.gz) to get a "full" Yabasic. But there are also downsides; this "centralised" approach could quickly become cluttered and confusing, there would need to be a more stringent process for "officially" adopting modules, and users would find it more difficult to develop their own modules and share them. In my opinion, there's also a certain inelegance about it all: packing a bunch of source files together, each one written by a different author in a different style... maybe I'm just not pragmatic enough.
Which approach should we choose? I'll pass the microphone—or, rather, the comment button—to you.
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.